Find a Dinner Restaurant in New Lebanon, NY

Dine on fresh-made pizza and flatbreads

What are you hungry for tonight? If it's wood-fired pizza and flatbreads or creamy pasta, M&M'S Tap and Tavern is your go-to spot. Our dinner restaurant in New Lebanon, New York serves up delicious meals made in-house. Whether you're in the mood for savory shepard's pie or sweet and spicy wings, you'll find a meal you'll love. Plus, our portions are big-you won't leave hungry.

Explore our options for pizza and flatbreads at M&M'S Tap and Tavern in New Lebanon, New York today.

Try the dishes our guests love

Try the dishes our guests love

Are you ready to find your new favorite meal at our dinner restaurant? We're well-known for a lot of tasty dishes. If you go crazy for cheese, you can try our wood-fired baked mac and cheese made with four cheeses. Maybe wings are your thing. Our flavors range from mild to spicy. You can even try our perfect 10 sauce-a blend of super-hot peppers and sauces.

Sit down to a delicious meal made with wholesome ingredients. Call 518-794-6102 now to learn more about our dinner options.


Mozzarella Sticks


Handmade, triple breaded mozzarella sticks served with marinara.

French Onion Soup


(Tavern specialty)

Guinness Beer Chili


Banging Shrimp


Lightly breaded, flash fried shrimp, tossed in an Asian style sauce.

Buffalo Chicken Dip


Always a house party favorite, M's famous buffalo dip is now available at the tavern. Served with house fried tortilla chips.

Spinach & Artichoke Dip


Spinach & Artichoke dip topped with mozzarella and heated in our wood fired oven. Served with house fried tortilla chips.

Loaded Fries


Fresh Cut Fries Loaded with Cheese and Bacon

Chili Cheese Fries


Fresh Cut Fries topped with Chili, Cheddar Cheese & Sour Cream

Side of Fries


Side of Sweet Fries


Side of Whiskey Battered Onion Rings


Additional Sides of Sauce



Wings 1LB - 12.95 | 1.5LB - 15.95 | 3LB - 26.96 | Boneless Wings $10

Wing Flavors: Buffalo, Mild, Medium, Hot, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Buffalo Garlic Parmesan, Honey BBQ, Chipotle, Bourbon
An order of ten large juicy buffalo wings cooked crispy & tossed in one of our homemade sauces. Served with celery & ranch dressing. Our Homemade Blue Cheese $.50.
At M&M's we are so passionate about our wings.
Wood Fired Twice Baked Wings +$2
They start in the kitchen and get baked again in the wood fired oven, a simply sophisticated chant in taste to our normal wings
flavorful & can be enjoyed by all
full flavor with some heat
HOTT!!! No amateurs
it hurts & will cause sweat, tears & temporary facial distortion


Dressing: Blue Cheese, Ranch, Honey Mustard, Balsamic Vinaigrette, White Balsamic, Italian, Greek, and Oil & Vinegar
Add Crispy or Grilled Chicken $3

Tossed Salad


Tomatoes, Onions, Green Peppers & shredded Mozzarella, with your choice of dressing.

Side Salad


Tomatoes, onions, green peppers & shredded mozzarella, with choice of dressing.

Caesar Salad


Romaine lettuce with house-made Caesar dressing, croutons & Parmesan cheese.

Side Caeser Salad


Buffalo Chicken Salad


Crispy or grilled Buffalo Chicken, lettuce, tomato, Cheddar cheese, blue cheese crumbles & celery, served with our homemade blue cheese dressing.

fresh mozzarella salad


Sliced Tomato, Sliced Fresh Grande Mozzarella, Onions Over Pesto topped with a Balsamic reduction Drizzle

Mexican Salad


Seasoned ground beef, tomatoes, onions, black olives, jalapeños, cheddar cheese, served in our house made tortilla bowl with sour cream & salsa


Our Burgers are Delivered Exclusively from a local meatpacker. Always fresh never frozen ground beef. Hand-packed to a 1/2 LB Burger experience you won't forget! Served with seasoned chips.

Upgrade to fresh-cut fries for $1 - Sweet potato fries for $1.50 - Whiskey Battered Onion Rings for $2 - Side Salad for $3 /b>

the redneck round up


Classic bacon cheese burger combo topped with A1 & ketchup.

cajun blue


Our house made cajun seasoning, bacon and a marbled blue cheese.

bourbon burger


Our Jim Beam Bourbon glaze, on top of a half-pound handpacked burger, with cheddar cheese & onion straws.

sweet heat


Stephentown-made Habarnaro garlic jam, fresh mozzarella & bacon.

lone ranger


Mushrooms, caramelized onions, Swiss cheese & bacon aioli sauce.

the cowboy burger


half-pound burger topped with sliced cheddar cheese, bacon, barbecue sauce & crispy onion straws.

byo burger


Build your own burger with a variety of toppings. Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, A1, Ketchup, Hot Sauce, BBQ Sauce, Onion Straws, Marbled Blue Cheese, Swiss, American, Cheddar & mozzarella $1 each. Bacon $2.
*Substitute chicken or veggie burger.


SM 10" |LG 14" | GF Crust +4 | Calzone 13

Hand Tossed Fresh Dough Made Daily, Premium Cheeses, Vine Ripe Tomato Sauce with Fresh Ingredients.


HOUSE SAUCE: Traditional old-world style pizza sauce.

ROBUST: A zesty pizza sauce, a tad thicker & bolder than the house sauce

PESTO: Basil, olive oil sauce.

WHITE: Garlic butter, olive oil sauce.

Specialty Pizza

buffalo chicken

$13 • $17

A Tavern perfection made with our homemade Buffalo Sauce, Topped with Fresh Diced Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, served with a side of our Homemade Blue cheese.

barbecue chicken

$13 • $17

Similar to our Buffalo Chicken but with Barbecue Sauce instead.

m's combo

$13 • $17

Pepperoni, Sausage, green pepper, mushroom & onion.


$13 • $17

Our traditional pizza sauce topped with hand-shredded basil, sliced tomato & fresh mozzarella.

meat lovers

$15 • $19

Robust sauce, Ham, pepperoni, Sausage, bacon & meatball come together for a delicious, anti-vegetable, pizza lovers dream.


$13 • $17

House Sauce, bacon, sliced tomatoes & spinach.

veggie supreme

$13 • $17

Onions, green peppers, mushrooms & tomatoes.

the great white

$13 • $17

Our white garlic sauce, Sausage, Ricotta & broccoli.


Available after 4:30pm
Please Allow Additional Time Dishes Are Made from Scratch

wood fired shepherds pie


Beer braised shredded beef brisket, mashed potato, carrots, corn, baked in our wood fired oven & served in a skillet.

chicken parm


Large chicken breast pounded thin, hand-breaded & pan-seared, covered with mozzarella & marinara. Served with angel hair pasta & house-baked garlic bread.

wood fired baked mac n cheese


[A tavern specialty - homemade 4 cheese mac n cheese]
Loaded Mac n Cheese $16
stuffed with bacon, cheddar cheese, sour cream & chives
Buffalo Mac n Cheese $16
with blue cheese crumbles & our buffalo wing sauce



Chicken, broccoli & tomato with penne pasta, in a homemade creamy alfredo sauce.

Kid's Menu

All kid's meals are served with fresh cut fries and a drink. Apple sauce is available in place of French fries.

chicken fingers


cheese quesadilla


grilled cheese


pasta with butter or red sauce



Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mug Root Beer, Mountain Dew, Sierra Mist, Sobe Yum Berry Pomegranate Life Water
$3.50 (1 Free Refill)

Shirly Temple $3.50

Lemonade, Unsweetened Iced Tea, Milk, Chocolate Milk, Coffee (Reg & Decaf) $3